In today’s competitive job market, having a compelling and well-crafted CV is crucial for landing your dream job, and for most professionals CV writing services are the go-to for helping stand out among the sea of applicants. However, with the rise of artificial intelligence (AI) technologies, AI CV services have emerged as an alternative option, but does it help in finding a new role, the right role with the right company – in this article, we will explore the pros and cons of using AI CV services compared to human professional CV writing services.
So, let’s look at AI – to begin with, anything that doesn’t come with a 1-2-1 conversation will only be based on the information you give it, so with AI you must ensure that you are feeding it correct and relevant detail, you also need to be very clear on your target direction.
With a human, experienced and professional CV writer they can hold a discussion with you that finds out the information needed to make your CV personal to you, capturing relevancy, impact and what makes you the perfect candidate for the vacancy, role, team and company you are going for!
The key advantages and disadvantages of AI and Human services;
One of the most significant advantages of using AI CV services is the speed at which they can create a CV, there is no doubting that AI algorithms can compile information from your input, such as your education, work experience, and skills, to generate a CV in a matter of minutes! This can be a considerable advantage when you need a CV quickly, such as for a job application deadline. To get the most from a human CV writer you will need to be able to give some dedicated time to speak with them and allow them to work their experienced magic to create you a compelling, achievement focused CV that is unique to you, but timewise this takes more like days than minutes!
From an accessible perspective, AI CV services are available 24/7, they don’t sleep and can be accessed from anywhere in the world with an internet connection – this accessibility makes them an attractive option for individuals with busy schedules or those in different time zones who may not be able to coordinate with a human CV writer easily. But a professional, human CV writer worth their salt will make themselves available when you are, this may not be at 2am as humans do need to sleep, but most definitely daytimes, evenings and weekends.
AI CV services rely on algorithms and data-driven analysis to create CVs, this means that they can’t always provide an objective perspective on your qualifications and suggest improvements based on industry-specific trends and requirements, this is where a professional human CV writer will come into its own!
There are Pros and Cons with any service that you choose to adopt to help you, and with the debate of is AI better than a Human’ then there are some key differences;
AI based CVs V Professional CV Writer CVs
The main difference will be that AI doesn’t get to know you, it can’t ask you questions that drive specific detail and it can’t ‘know’ what you have done and achieved in your own career, so in effect an AI CV will lack personalisation, tend to feel generic and fail to capture your individuality – whereas professional human writers can talk to you, ask questions and dig deeper into your experiences and accomplishments, making your CV more personalised and unique.
AI CV services may struggle to understand the context of your work experiences, achievements, and goals. They can miss nuances and fail to highlight crucial details that a human writer might recognise and emphasise; AI CV services are limited by the algorithms and data they rely on, they may not adapt well to unconventional career paths, gaps in employment, or unique qualifications; AI CV services are constrained by their programming and lack creativity. While they can produce well-structured and professional-looking CVs, they may struggle to craft engaging and memorable content that can set you apart from other applicants.
Professional Human CV writers can provide a personalised and tailored service; they can engage in one-on-one consultations, ask probing questions about your career goals, achievements, and aspirations to create a CV that truly reflects your unique qualities. They possess the ability to understand the context of your work experiences and accomplishments, and highlight relevant achievements, skills, and qualifications, ensuring your CV resonates with hiring managers in your industry. Human CV writers are more adaptable when it comes to handling complex career situations, such as employment gaps or career changes – they can craft a compelling narrative that addresses potential concerns and showcases your strengths. And don’t forget us human writers excel at storytelling and creativity, which can make your CV more engaging and memorable which can captivate hiring managers and leave a lasting impression. And lastly, human professional CV writers often provide quality assurance by thoroughly reviewing and editing your CV to eliminate errors, inconsistencies, and formatting issues – this level of attention to detail can enhance the overall quality of your CV.
Some further thoughts to consider
Cost: the primary drawback of human professional CV services is that they have bills to pay so they do charge for their services, experience and skills, and this is always going to be more expensive than AI alternatives, making them less accessible to individuals on a tight budget.
Time: working with a human CV writer often involves having to chat with them, and although this is what makes them better it can be time-consuming; if you have a tight deadline, this may not be the most suitable option, and here AI may provide a quick solution.
In the ongoing debate between AI CV services and human professional CV writing services, there is no one-size-fits-all answer. The choice ultimately depends on your specific needs, budget, and preferences. AI CV services offer speed, efficiency, and cost-effectiveness but may lack the personal touch and contextual understanding of human writers. On the other hand, human professional CV writers excel at personalisation, creativity, and quality assurance but can be costly and time-consuming.
I asked my LinkedIn audience what their preference would be in using AI or a Professional CV Writer (human) to work with on their CV/job search documentation and the result of the poll was 25% AI v 75% Human – at this moment in time professionals are opting for the human touch as opposed to AI!
I went one step further and asked ChatGPT the following questions, and this is what it said;
The Question: Can you answer the question ‘are AI CVs more effective than one written by a Professional CV Writer’?
The Answer (ChatGPT): The effectiveness of a CV (Curriculum Vitae) created by an AI versus one written by a professional CV writer depends on several factors and can vary depending on individual circumstances. Here are some considerations:
Customisation:
AI-generated CVs can be useful for creating a basic CV quickly, but they lack the customisation and personalisation that a professional CV writer can provide.
A professional writer can tailor the CV to your specific skills, experiences, and job preferences, making it more compelling to potential employers.
Human Touch:
Professional CV writers understand the nuances of language, storytelling, and branding. They can craft a CV that not only lists your qualifications but also tells a compelling career story and highlights your unique strengths.
ChatGPT – had no content to input.
Industry Expertise:
A professional CV writer with industry-specific knowledge can understand the requirements and expectations of different sectors. This can be particularly valuable if you’re targeting a niche job market.
ChatGPT – had no content to input.
Quality Control:
Professional CV writers can ensure that the CV is free from errors, adheres to best practices, and follows industry-specific conventions.
AI-generated CVs may produce errors or awkward phrasing that could negatively impact your chances.
Relevance:
Human CV writers can help you emphasise the most relevant skills and experiences for a particular job or industry, increasing your chances of getting noticed by hiring managers; and when working with a professional CV writer, you can provide input and collaborate on the document’s content, style, and direction.
ChatGPT – had no content to input.
Ethical Considerations:
Some AI-powered CV generators have faced ethical concerns about biases and misinformation.
A human CV writer can be more sensitive to these issues and ensure the document is unbiased and accurate.
AI-generated CVs do have some advantages, such as speed, cost-effectiveness, and the ability to generate multiple versions quickly. They can be a good starting point for creating a CV, but it’s often advisable to have a professional review and customise the AI-generated CV to make it more effective.
In summary, while AI can be a helpful tool for creating a basic CV, a professionally written CV can be more effective in conveying your unique qualities, optimising your document for specific job applications, and adhering to industry standards.
I think this says it all – AI has a place in our world, but it isn’t going to be the answer to all your prayers from a CV / Job Search perspective, us humans still have one up on AI (for now!)…
If you need help with your CV, or any other document for your job search then simply get in touch and see if we can help you;
Recent Comments